RS21: The Five Pillars
Shahadah: declaration of faith and its place in Muslim practice
Shahadah: declaration of faith and its place in Muslim practice
The Shahadah is whispered into the ear of a newborn baby and is the last words a Muslim tries to say before death. It is recited in every salah (prayer) and in the call to prayer (adhan).
Q1: Explain why the Shahadah is the most important Pillar of Islam.
Students often think jihad means "holy war." Wrong: "Jihad means holy war." Correct: "Jihad means "struggle" or "striving." Greater jihad is the internal spiritual struggle to live as a good Muslim. Lesser jihad is armed struggle, which has strict conditions and is a last resort."
12 marks: Evaluate the view that shahadah: declaration of faith and its place in muslim practice.
A strong 12-mark answer will: (1) Present a religious viewpoint with specific teaching/scripture; (2) Present a contrasting religious or non-religious viewpoint; (3) Analyse the strengths and weaknesses of each position; (4) Reach a justified conclusion. For top marks, show awareness of diversity within traditions, use precise terminology, and demonstrate independent critical thinking rather than just rehearsing arguments.
Mark scheme: AO1 (knowledge and understanding) = 6 marks; AO2 (analysis and evaluation) = 6 marks
AO1 — Knowledge: Show precise knowledge of The Five Pillars, using specialist vocabulary and referring to sources of wisdom and authority (e.g. scripture, sacred texts).
AO2 — Application: Apply your understanding of The Five Pillars to religious and non-religious contexts. Explain how beliefs influence actions and practices.
AO3 — Analysis & Evaluation: Evaluate different views on The Five Pillars, including denominational or cross-tradition differences. Analyse strengths and weaknesses of arguments and reach a justified conclusion.
The Shahadah (“There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is his messenger”) is not merely a statement of belief but the foundation upon which every aspect of Muslim life is built. It is recited in every rak’ah (unit) of prayer, meaning a practising Muslim says it at least 17 times daily during the five daily prayers. The Shahadah is whispered into the ear of a newborn baby, symbolising that the first words a person hears are the declaration of faith. It is also the last words a Muslim strives to say before death. When a person wishes to convert to Islam, reciting the Shahadah sincerely before witnesses is all that is required — there is no elaborate ceremony or initiation ritual. The importance of the Shahadah is emphasised in the Hadith: “Islam is based on five principles: to testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and Muhammad is Allah’s Messenger...” (Sahih Bukhari).
The Shahadah has two inseparable parts that define Muslim belief and practice. The first part (“There is no god but Allah”) affirms tawhid — the absolute oneness of God — and rejects all forms of shirk (associating partners with God). This is why Muslims reject the Christian concept of the Trinity and the Hindu worship of multiple deities: both are seen as compromising the oneness of God. The second part (“Muhammad is his messenger”) affirms risalah — the belief that Muhammad is the final prophet in a line of prophets that includes Ibrahim (Abraham), Musa (Moses) and Isa (Jesus). Accepting Muhammad as Allah’s messenger means accepting the Qur’an as God’s final and complete revelation. Surah 112 (Al-Ikhlas), which succinctly expresses tawhid, is sometimes called ‘the equivalent of one-third of the Qur’an’ because it distils the essence of the faith.
This concept is frequently tested in GCSE RS exams. When writing about the shahadah in daily muslim life, always use specific religious terminology, reference sacred texts, and explain how the teaching affects the lives of believers today. A strong answer would include both the theoretical teaching and its practical application, considering different denominational or scholarly perspectives where relevant.
While all Muslims recognise the Five Pillars, Sunni and Shi’a traditions express their core practices differently. Sunni Muslims follow the Five Pillars as the essential framework of Islamic practice: Shahadah, Salah, Zakah, Sawm and Hajj. These Five Pillars are considered obligatory (fard) for all Sunni Muslims. Shi’a Muslims follow the Ten Obligatory Acts (Furu al-Din), which include the Five Pillars plus additional practices: Khums (a 20% tax on surplus income paid to religious leaders), Jihad (striving in the way of Allah), Amr bil Ma’ruf (encouraging good), Nahi an al-Munkar (forbidding evil), and Tawalla (loving the Ahl al-Bayt — the family of the Prophet) and Tabarra (disassociating from the enemies of the Ahl al-Bayt).
The differences reflect distinct theological and historical traditions. For Sunni Muslims, the Five Pillars represent the practical expression of the Shahadah, the minimum obligations that define a Muslim’s relationship with Allah. They are rooted in the Qur’an and the Sunnah (the practice of the Prophet). For Shi’a Muslims, the Ten Obligatory Acts reflect the guidance of the Imams, whom they believe were divinely appointed to lead the Muslim community after the Prophet’s death. The inclusion of khums (a 20% tax rather than the Sunni 2.5% zakah) reflects the Shi’a belief in the authority of the Imams and their descendants to receive and distribute religious funds. Despite these differences, both traditions share the same core practices of prayer, fasting, charity and pilgrimage, and both affirm the Shahadah as the central declaration of faith.
This concept is frequently tested in GCSE RS exams. When writing about sunni and shi’a understandings of the pillars, always use specific religious terminology, reference sacred texts, and explain how the teaching affects the lives of believers today. A strong answer would include both the theoretical teaching and its practical application, considering different denominational or scholarly perspectives where relevant.
For Muslims in Britain, the Five Pillars provide a framework for living as a religious minority in a secular society. Observing the Five Pillars requires commitment and sometimes sacrifice: praying five times daily means fitting prayer around work or school schedules; fasting during Ramadan in a society where most people are eating and drinking normally requires willpower; paying zakah requires financial planning; and performing Hajj requires saving for travel and taking extended leave from work. Despite these challenges, the 2021 Census recorded approximately 3.9 million Muslims in England and Wales (6.5% of the population), and surveys consistently show high levels of religious observance among British Muslims.
The Five Pillars also shape British Muslim community life. Jummah (Friday congregational) prayers bring Muslims together weekly, strengthening community bonds. During Ramadan, mosques host iftar (fast-breaking) meals open to all, and charitable giving increases significantly — Islamic Relief UK raises millions of pounds annually, much of it during Ramadan. The Hajj journey creates bonds between British Muslims and the global ummah, as approximately 25,000 British Muslims perform Hajj each year. However, some British Muslims find it challenging to maintain all Five Pillars in a secular environment: shift work may disrupt prayer times; school or university schedules may conflict with Ramadan fasting; and the cost of Hajj (typically £5,000–£10,000) puts it beyond the reach of many. These challenges have led to creative adaptations, such as prayer apps, online zakah calculators and flexible Hajj travel packages.
| Pillar | Sunni Practice | Shi’a Practice | Key Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shahadah | “There is no god but Allah...” | Same, plus reference to Ali | Shi’a add reference to Ali as Allah’s wali (guardian) |
| Salah | Five daily prayers at set times | Five daily prayers, often combined into three | Shi’a combine prayers; different postures |
| Zakah / Khums | 2.5% of surplus wealth annually | Zakah plus khums (20% of surplus income) | Shi’a pay both zakah and khums |
| Sawm | Fasting during Ramadan | Same, plus additional recommended fasts | Shi’a observe extra fasts, e.g. Day of Ashura |
| Hajj | Pilgrimage to Makkah once if able | Same, plus pilgrimage to Shi’a holy sites | Shi’a also visit shrines of the Imams |
Q: Explain two reasons why the Shahadah is the most important Pillar of Islam.
Q: “The Five Pillars are impossible to follow in modern Britain.” Evaluate this statement.
| Branch | Key Beliefs Framework | Authority Structure |
|---|---|---|
| Sunni | Six Articles of Faith, Five Pillars | Quran, Hadith, consensus (ijma) |
| Shia | Five Roots of Religion, Ten Obligatory Acts | Quran, Hadith, Imamate |
| Sufi | Inner spiritual dimension of Islam | Quran, Hadith, spiritual guides (sheikhs) |
Get the best revision books and guides to boost your grades.